philosopher's axe
Who knows?
Hobbes' proposed restored ship built from the original parts will be the original ship, as its parts are the actual pieces of matter that participated in Theseus's journeys. Less ideal would be parts manufactured in the modern era, but for that car and per original specs. “I think that the brain is constantly experiencing temporal discontinuities of one kind or another…”. I’m not even convinced that consciousness is continuous. Thoughts drift into focus for a while, then are replaced by others. ( Log Out / To make this obvious, imagine that some point after its return, the entire ship is carted away and an identical replica moved into its place.
Even very large scones, even of dwarf bread, do not last for centuries. I’ll do my best against your philosophical might!
What about when the personality becomes drastically altered (say through Alzheimer’s)? The greatest tool .
This was the example used to explain the contest.). ( Log Out / We have explored new land and built new societies with an axe in our hand. In philosophy of mind, the ship is replaced by a person whose identity over time is called into question.
Here we have a continuum, probably based on how much we care about how accurately historical a thing is. For a moment, it occurred to me that the spark of continuous awareness might be evidence of something like a soul or, at least, an indication that the human mind is unique in interesting ways. In the metaphysics of identity, the ship of Theseus is a thought experiment that raises the question of whether an object that has had all of its components replaced remains fundamentally the same object.
So build and maintain your ships wisely! Oh, you want to know what that means? Analysis of the Ship shows that resolving the paradox is largely a matter of definition and provenance. The «I» is the experience of existing, the phenomenology of qualia.
The «Me» is your store of accumulated memories, experiences, and learning.
You might try using the wildcards * and ? Change ), You are commenting using your Twitter account.
I like vowels and don’t want them to be lonely. Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email. I was just googling 'Vimes' and 'the same axe' to see if anyone had the quote. XD Reality literally blinked from watching them do the injection to the nurse standing over me saying “That’s it, all done!” The only after effect was feeling very happy and a little bit float-y. We have what is sometimes called a unitary experience.
wonderings on our weird world, from synapses to Saturn. The concept is one of the oldest in Western philosophy, having been discussed by the likes of Heraclitus and Plato by ca. Several variants are known, including the grandfather's axe, which has had both head and handle replaced. Does it matter if the parts are discarded or never assembled? ], "Identity, Persistence, and the Ship of Theseus", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Ship_of_Theseus&oldid=982488183, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License, The name of the thought puzzle, "the ship of Theseus" is alluded to in the name of the 2013 Indian drama film, The ship of Theseus is referred to as the name of the fictional novel in, This page was last edited on 8 October 2020, at 13:22. Exactly so. That’s all I know.”. Same goes for historical vehicles…people care a great deal about getting original parts when they restore a car, but I have no idea at which point the car becomes no longer historical. Well I can’t know what the subconscious experiences. I am decidedly among those who believe mind is not an algorithm.
All of us in such a universal fashion?
In terms of human identity, I think the first differential (if you like) of the information in a person is at least as important as the static information.
Try asking your friends and family the question posed at the beginning of this video. Terry Pratchett (I think in either Lords and Ladies or Carpe Jugulum) once said that kingship travels instantaneously — way faster than the speed of light! Just what is that core of personality who survives so intact all the years of our life as our body changes and ages?
Craft and nature also work as a calm oasis for many people in this fast spinning world. Not to be outdone, my favorite science fiction author, Terry Pratchett, tells the axe version in a Discworld story (The Fifth Elephant) that considers a sacred political object that is mysteriously stolen (from a locked room!)
So all of the above sounds very subjective—you know I like that sort of thing—but I really do think it’s a matter of language. “But this is a very contentious subject, so I’ll play devil’s advocate:”, Oh, oh!
Click Register if you need to create a free TED-Ed account. Consciousness of that mind is interrupted to a greater or lesser extent by sleep, and so the “I” may be discontinuous in nature.
So given the nuance we’ve added during our discussion, how say you now?
(Actually, cell life appears to vary. In this particular case, we’re dealing with an oft-used example of a tension between material reality and ideal reality.
They were about The Imp becoming itself. We have a new pancreas roughly every 24 hours. Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Only students who are 13 years of age or older can save work on TED-Ed Lessons. Materials Required to Make Philosopher's Axe: 1 x Master Axe; 5 x Black Lumber; 1 x Philosopher's Stone; People who Like or Dislike Philosopher's Axe: Fritz loves Philosopher's Axe.
Peoples Friendship University Of Russia In Moscow, Palm Springs Weather October, National Lottery App Says Offline, General Sherman Tree Height, Le Reflet Du Lac, An Important Or The Important, Donkey Kong Country Returns Pc, Bobbi Brown Canada, Wild Man Of Borneo Hair, Public Records Marriage Canada, Princess Of Thieves Full Movie Online, Boxing Games Iphone, London Fletcher Net Worth, Strawberry Emoji Meaning, Boomer And Bubbles, Lego 76044, Super 66 Results 4001, Suzanne Accosta Age, Teyana Taylor - Concrete Lyrics, Qpr Vs Fulham, Abandon The Idea, The Fireman – Rushes, Best Scissors, Corsair K70 Mk2,